Download the Annual Equality Report 2023-24 (PDF)
Introduction
The Education Workforce Council (EWC) is the independent, professional regulator for the education workforce in Wales.
Established by the Education (Wales) Act 2014, we regulate education practitioners in 11 different registration categories spanning schools, further education, youth work, and work-based learning. Our Register of Education Practitioners is the biggest public register of any profession in Wales and the most wide-ranging register of education professionals in the world, with over 90,000 practitioners registered.
Our commitment to equality and diversity is integral to the EWC and the way we work. Our Strategic Equality Plan (SEP) outlines how we will meet this commitment, as well as our legal obligations, in line with the Equality Act 2010, and the Wales specific public sector equality duty (the equality duty) therein.
In April 2020, following consultation with stakeholders, we published our SEP for the period 2020-24. The plan made clear our commitment, as an organisation, to delivering a series of specific equality objectives, and demonstrated our dedication to combating discrimination and promoting diversity. The SEP was accompanied by a series of action plans and annual monitoring reports.
During the period of the plan, we have undertaken annual reviews and made minor amendments only.
This annual equality report sets out the progress we have made in achieving our four equality objectives during 2023-24.
Our equality processes and procedures
Compliance with our equalities duties is a standing agenda item at monthly senior management team meetings, providing a formal forum to discuss updates or matters arising.
In April 2023, our equality processes and procedures were subject to a regulatory compliance audit which gave substantial assurance and no recommendations.
Equality impact assessments
To ensure that equality is at the forefront of our work and to meet our legal obligations, all relevant policies and procedures must undergo an equality impact assessment (EqIA). All EqIAs are stored in a library and are part of the development and approval process for any new (or reviewed) policy. This helps us to ensure that our decisions are evidence-based and have specific regard to equalities.
During the reporting period, we have begun a review to further develop the process of completing EqIAs. Work on this will continue during 2024-25, with the aim of ensuring that our processes are both efficient and effective.
A summary of EqIAs is scrutinised by the senior management team at its monthly meetings.
Procurement
As a public body, we have a responsibility for ensuring that equality is at the core of our procurement processes. Our procurement policy includes a specific section about equality. This ensures that all contractors and subcontractors providing a service to us are aware of their obligations in helping us achieve our commitment to eliminate unlawful discrimination on the grounds of any of the protected characteristics. It also makes clear the requirement on them to promote equality of opportunity and good relations between all members of society. A section on equality is also included in our procurement statement which is published on our website.
Engagement
Throughout the reporting year, we met with key stakeholders and networks where we have discussed issues relating to equality, appropriate to our remit. We have highlighted relevant equalities information to our registrants and other stakeholders throughout the year (which we discuss in greater detail below).
We have also participated in a number of equalities networks, groups, and partnerships, gaining invaluable insight and learning, including lived experiences, which inform our work, these have included:
- Public Sector Equality Duty (PSED) Network
- South East Wales Equalities Network (SEWEN)
- BAMEed Network Wales
- Anti-Racist Wales FE Steering Group
- Diversity and Anti-Racist Professional Learning (DARPL)
- Wales Equality and Human Rights Exchange Network
- Colegau Cymru Equality and Diversity group
Achieving our objectives
Objective 1: monitor our employment practices to identify barriers to recruitment and career progression
How will we achieve this objective?
We will monitor our employment practices. This will include examining staff remuneration and looking at staff, Council and committee/panel members[1] recruitment processes and career progression, with the aim of identifying and addressing any barriers that exist to the development of a diverse workforce and governance structure.
We will:
- review and, where necessary, improve recruitment processes for staff, Council and committee/panel members[1], to help deliver a diverse workforce, ensuring fairness to all under-represented groups
- analyse remuneration for all staff, to understand whether any pay gap exists, taking measures to rectify any issues that are uncovered
- identify barriers for staff, Council and committee/panel members1 in accessing training and development opportunities and take steps to remove these
Progress in 2023-24
Staff equalities data is collected annually through a survey and used to inform impact assessments, policy development, and training plans. In our most recent survey, of the 56 staff in post at the time, 50 responses were received (89% response rate). Our staff profile can be seen in annex A.
Our pay scales are transparent and employees receive annual increments until they reach the maximum rate for their pay band. We currently follow Welsh Government’s pay scales. When Welsh Government agree a pay increase, we review this and, if accepted by us as the employer, we formally adopt it. Our gender pay information is reviewed annually. Information for 2023-24 can be found in annex A.
As an organisation, we use the performance and development review (PDR) process to identify individual training and development needs, review progress, and discuss any barriers to access. All employees have equality of opportunity regarding training, where it is considered relevant to the role. We also analyse training completed each year for equality monitoring purposes. As all employee equality data is anonymised, no specific data relating to the protected characteristics of employees who undertook individual training is available. Further details about training provided in 2023-24 can be found under objective two.
We continuously review our recruitment processes to identify and address potential barriers. All posts are advertised externally to reach a wide range of applicants and include a positive statement to encourage applications from a wide and diverse range of individuals. Our short, accessible animation summarising the EWC as an organisation, outlines our staff values, positive organisational culture, and inclusive recruitment processes.
We collect diversity information for all direct applicants, but our application process ensures that all references to names, contact details, or other potential indicators of protected characteristics are anonymised prior to commencing the sift process. In this reporting year, we advertised 16 posts and received 80 diversity monitoring forms. Further details about the profile of applicants can be found in annex A.
Equality information relating to our Council members, in respect of the nine protected characteristics, is also collected. Council members are appointed by Welsh Government through the public appointments system. Whilst we have no jurisdiction over this process, the information we collect can help inform it.
Following Welsh Government’s recruitment process in 2023, six new members were appointed and six members reappointed. Together, they formed the new Council that commenced term on 1 April 2023. Further recruitment activity has continued as Welsh Government seeks to find suitable individuals to fill the remaining two vacancies, with the intention of using these appointments to enhance the ethnic diversity of the Council. We have again supported Welsh Government with this recruitment by signposting the vacancies to our registrants, stakeholders, and networks.
Where we do have jurisdiction in appointing panel members[2], we seek to attract a wide range of candidates, representative of the diverse landscape of the education workforce in Wales. This year, we have started to collect equality information from our fitness to practise panel members and Initial Teacher Education Accreditation (ITEA) board members. We will continue to do this on an annual basis to further inform future recruitment exercises.
During 2024-25, we will also start to formally collect equality information from our pool of Quality Mark for Youth Work (QMYW) in Wales assessors.
Our processes to monitor our employment practices to identify any barriers to recruitment and career progression are reported to our Council.
[1] Including members of the Fitness to Practise (FtP) committee, Initial Teacher Education (ITE) accreditation board, and Quality Mark for Youth Work (QMYW) assessors.
[2] Including members of the FtP committee, ITE accreditation board, and QMYW assessors.
Objective 2: develop an inclusive EWC workforce culture
How will we achieve this objective?
We will work to ensure that our organisation is inclusive, welcoming, and understanding to all employees, Council and committee/panel members1, in order that they are able to be themselves and can perform to the best of their ability.
We will:
- support staff who have caring responsibilities
- foster greater awareness of equalities amongst our employees
- ensure that our bullying and harassment policies remain up to date
- work to tackle mental health stigma and discrimination, in line with the EWC's mental health and well-being policies, and our commitment to the Time to Change Pledge
Progress in 2023-24
In February 2023, we introduced a formal hybrid working policy which allows staff to combine working in the office with working from home. This was reviewed in February 2024 with no changes made in relation to the flexibility it offers. We also offer a flexi-time system for all employees.
April 2023 saw the launch of our second annual wellbeing programme which offered a wide range of activities and opportunities to support staff. We consult with staff, ask for feedback on the current programme, and seek suggestions for future activities regularly via our employee forum.
In September 2023, we launched our first internal equality, diversity, and inclusion newsletter which is published to all staff quarterly. A key tool to helping us embed our commitment to equality and diversity across the organisation, the newsletter offers staff information and support about equality topics, and encourages engagement with awareness days and campaigns.
24/7 access to the Care First employee assistance support helpline is available to everyone in the EWC. It offers confidential advice on a range of issues. We have shared information with staff about the free wellbeing webinars available to them through Care First.
In addition, all staff are provided with regular training in relation to the equality duty and our annual training plan includes at least one mandatory session for all staff on equality matters. This year, staff completed an online training module on equality, diversity, and inclusion awareness, and attended a neurodiversity workshop led by The Brain Charity. When a new member of staff is appointed, the induction process includes an overview of the equality duty.
We currently have three members of staff who are trained as mental health first aiders and a further two will undertake the training in 2024-25.
We include equality inputs in annual training for Council and committee/panel members[3], encouraging open dialogue surrounding discrimination and lived experiences to advance equality of opportunity and foster good relations between people who share a protected characteristic and those who do not.
[3] Including members of the FtP committee, ITE accreditation board, and QMYW assessors.
Objective 3: ensure our services meet the needs of diverse registrants and stakeholders (including those with protected characteristics) and support our registrants to implement fair and inclusive professional practice
How will we achieve this objective?
As the independent regulator for the education workforce in Wales, we must ensure that we identify any barriers that our registrants and other stakeholders might face when interacting with us. This includes learners and parents/guardians. We also need to support our registrants to implement fair and inclusive professional practice.
We will:
- consult and engage with registrants and stakeholders regarding whether our services meet their diverse needs
- identify any barriers faced by registrants and stakeholders when interacting with the EWC and take steps to remove these, as appropriate and proportionate
- review and publish fitness to practise data to monitor the appropriateness of guidance and inform training needs
- promote awareness of equality and diversity issues within the education workforce to enhance professional practice
Progress in 2023-24
We are committed to making our bilingual communications and information as accessible as possible.
Following a full review, we have comprehensively redesigned our website, incorporating a number of improvements in areas such as accessibility, user journey, branding, and layout. The new website launched in May 2023 following which we sought feedback from service users to inform further improvements. We ensure that the information provided is logically and consistently located, and straightforward to find via a search facility.
Our website currently conforms to level AA standard of the Web Content Accessibility Guidelines (WCAG) 2.1. The accessibility of our website was audited by the Government Digital Service (GDS) in December 2023 which identified some minor issues, however, these were quickly resolved. We offer users of our website access to the ReachDeck Toolbar, web accessibility software which supports people with visual impairments and hidden disabilities, as well as those who lack basic digital skills and people who wish to read the website in a language other than Welsh or English.
All video content (with sound) that is added to our website in Welsh and English is fully captioned. Any audio only content (such as podcasts) is uploaded with an accompanying transcript in both Welsh and English. Whilst our publications are usually in electronic format, we do offer alternative formats on request. An increasing number of our publications are also now published in HTML format, as well as other accessible formats. We continue to review our publications to ensure they are accessible and inclusive for our registrants and the public.
We have held a number of online events throughout the year. Registration to these events has been facilitated through Ticket Source. This platform allows attendees to indicate any reasonable adjustments they may require for an event. We have made adjustments for four attendees during the year, including providing advice to an attendee on how to access the live subtitling facility in the event platform and providing presentation slides to another in advance of the event.
BSL interpretation has been provided for deaf and hard of hearing professionals or registrants who have been involved in virtual fitness to practise meetings.
For service users who wish to receive paper copies of any of our documentation, we provide this upon request via post.
Throughout the reporting year, we have discussed equalities issues appropriate to our remit when meeting with key stakeholders and interest groups. These have included representatives from BAMEed Network Wales, DARPL, and Urban Circle Newport leading to a number of collaborative projects, including:
- partnering with DARPL to help organise and promote Wales’ first national diversity and anti-racist leadership conference, which took place in June 2023
- recording an episode of our new podcast series, ‘Sgwrsio with the EWC’ focussing on diversifying Wales’ education workforce
We’ve also attended meetings of the SEWEN, PSED Network, and the Anti-Racist Wales FE Steering Group, and a number of events and webinars focused on equality issues. This included the Black Leadership Group’s annual conference, which took place in the Senedd in March 2024.
We continue to gather equality data from registrants who are subject to FtP proceedings through our case management system. In August 2023, we published our fitness to practise annual report, which included equality data for all registrant groups.
To support our registrants, and increase awareness of mental health issues, we have made several recommendations through Meddwl Mawr (our book and journal club) to resources on topics including mindfulness, supporting learners with dyslexia, lesson planning, and equitable education.
In June 2023, we published the findings from the Further Education and Work-Based Learning Education Workforce Survey 2023, which we conducted on behalf of conducted on behalf of the national workload steering group (made up of representatives from Welsh Government, Joint Trade Union Wales, and Colegau Cymru). The survey asked questions on practitioners’ perceptions of their role and career, working patterns and workload, wellbeing and professional learning.
Objective 4: promote the development of a diverse education workforce in Wales
How will we achieve this objective?
Our regulatory responsibilities include promoting careers in the education professions and advising Welsh Government on matters related to the education workforce and teaching and learning. We will use our influence in this area to help promote the development of a more diverse education workforce.
We will:
- use our data to monitor and highlight issues relating to equality and diversity across all of our registrant groups
- promote diversity within the education workforce as part of a broader campaign to promote careers within the workforce
Progress in 2023-24
The Register of Education Practitioners offers a high-quality evidence base in relation to equality and diversity issues. We have undertaken a number of actions throughout the year to ensure the quality and completeness of the data held on our Register. In September 2023, we published the Annual Education Workforce Statistics for Wales 2023. This included equalities data on practitioners across all 11 of our registrant groups. We have also published other statistical releases throughout the year which have included equalities data, ITE student results, and data on newly qualified teachers.
In August 2023, we signed the Race Council Cymru Zero Racism Wales pledge, demonstrating our commitment to promoting racial harmony and equity through implementing the principles it sets out.
In November 2023, in collaboration with Welsh Government, we allocated ITE intake numbers to ITE partnerships for programmes commencing in September 2024. As part of this, we provided partnerships with specific requirements for the recruitment of Welsh medium teachers and teachers from black, Asian and minority ethnic communities (5% of total recruitment). We monitor recruitment to programmes and report on this to Welsh Government.
Content for Educators Wales (the brand and website that supports the promotion of careers in the education professions in Wales) has been reviewed and further developed in order to ensure that the pages depict a diverse workforce.
Our advocacy and support team has developed recruitment and engagement plans which include targeted recruitment activity for black, Asian and minority ethnic people. To lead the implementation of these targeted plans, we have a dedicated recruitment and support officer in post (a role for which we actively encouraged applications from black, Asian and minority ethnic candidates). Work in this area has included ongoing engagement with diverse groups from across Wales, including the North Wales African Society, Welsh Islamic Cultural Association, Cardiff Council Race Equality Taskforce, , BAME Mental Health Service, South Riverside Community Development Centre, Swansea Council for Voluntary Service, and secondary schools with a high proportion of students identifying as black, Asian and minority ethnic.
Annex A – employment information
Number of people employed by protected characteristic
We gather staff equalities data through our annual staff survey. When requesting the information, we inform staff that completion of the form is voluntary, but in doing so, we will be better enabled to understand the composition of our workforce and examine our practices fully. This gives us an opportunity to target our activities and priorities where any under-representation or inequalities are found. The data is used to inform impact assessments, policy development, and training plans. Our most recent survey took place in March 2024.
Of the 56 staff in post at the time, 50 responses were received (89% response rate). Due to the size of our organisation, figures accounting for 10% or less of the responses have been redacted (represented by an *) to prevent individuals from being identified.
Age
16-24 | * |
---|---|
25-34 | 19 |
35-44 | 10 |
45-54 | 11 |
55-64 | 7 |
65 & over | * |
Prefer not to say | * |
Gender/Sex
Male | 14 |
---|---|
Female | 36 |
Non-Binary | * |
Intersex | * |
Prefer not to say | * |
Are you trans?
Yes | * |
---|---|
No | 49 |
Prefer not to say | * |
Did not respond | * |
Sexual orientation
Bisexual | * |
---|---|
Gay/lesbian | * |
Heterosexual | 43 |
Prefer not to say | * |
Relationship status
Married or in a civil partnership | 19 |
---|---|
Divorced | * |
Single | 13 |
Living with a partner in a long-term relationship | 13 |
Partner | * |
Separated | * |
Widowed | * |
Prefer not to say | * |
Religion or belief
No religion | 27 |
---|---|
Atheist | * |
Christian | 19 |
Buddhist | * |
Hindu | * |
Humanist | * |
Jewish | * |
Muslim | * |
Pagan | * |
Sikh | * |
Prefer not to say | * |
Ethnicity
White – Welsh / English / Scottish / Northern Irish / British | 45 |
---|---|
Irish | * |
Mixed – White and Black Caribbean | * |
Mixed – White and Asian | * |
Asian / Asian British – Indian | * |
Asian / Asian British - Bangladeshi | * |
Other | * |
No response | * |
National identity
Welsh | 41 |
---|---|
English | * |
Scottish | * |
Irish | * |
British | 7 |
Other | * |
No response | * |
Caring responsibilities
None | 26 |
---|---|
Primary carer of a child/children (under 18) | 17 |
Primary carer of a disabled child/children | * |
Primary carer of a disabled adult (18 and over) | * |
Primary carer of older person/people (65 and over) | * |
Secondary carer | * |
Prefer not to say | * |
Disability – Do you consider yourself to have a disability?
Yes, day to day activities limited a lot | * |
---|---|
Yes, day to day activities limited a little | * |
No | 47 |
Not sure | * |
Prefer not to say | * |
Disability – Please tick those impairments or health conditions that apply to you
Learning impairment or disability (for example dyslexia, Downs syndrome, Autism etc.) | * |
---|---|
Long-term health condition (for example epilepsy, diabetes or cancer) | * |
Mental ill health (for example depression, anxiety, or schizophrenia) | * |
Mobility impairment | * |
Prefer not to say | * |
Disability – Do you have a disability, as defined by the Equality Act 2010? [4]
Yes | * |
---|---|
No | 47 |
Prefer not to say | * |
Recruitment data
Where possible, we collect and analyse equalities information relating to staff recruitment. In some instances, where limited applications are received and the use of a recruitment agency is necessary, equalities information is not always provided. Additionally, where internal staff apply for posts, completion of a diversity monitoring form is not mandatory.
In the reporting period, 16 posts were advertised for external recruitment. All direct candidates were provided with the opportunity to complete a diversity monitoring form at the point of application. We received 90 direct applications, from which we received 80 completed diversity monitoring forms. Categories where the response was zero have not been included in the data reported below.
Number of applications received by protected characteristic (where a diversity monitoring form was completed)
Age
16-24 | 10 |
---|---|
25-34 | 23 |
35-44 | 21 |
45-54 | 19 |
55-64 | 7 |
Gender/sex
Male | 18 |
---|---|
Female | 61 |
Non-binary | 1 |
Are you trans?
No | 78 |
---|---|
Unsure | 1 |
Did not respond | 1 |
Sexual orientation
Bisexual | 1 |
---|---|
Gay/lesbian | 4 |
Heterosexual | 72 |
Prefer not to say | 2 |
Did not respond | 1 |
Relationship status
Married | 30 |
---|---|
Divorced | 5 |
Single | 13 |
Living with a partner in a long-term relationship | 26 |
Partner | 3 |
Prefer not to say | 3 |
Religion or belief
No religion or belief | 41 |
---|---|
Atheist | 3 |
Christian (all denominations) | 28 |
Hindu | 1 |
Muslim | 1 |
Prefer not to say | 6 |
Ethnic group [5]
White – Welsh | 49 |
---|---|
White – English | 5 |
White - British | 13 |
Other white background | 6 |
Mixed/multiple ethnic group – white and Asian | 2 |
Other mixed/multiple ethnic group | 2 |
Asian/Asian British - Indian | 2 |
Asian/Asian British – Pakistani | 1 |
Asian/Asian British - Chinese | 1 |
Black/African/Caribbean/Black British - Caribbean | 1 |
Other Black/African/Caribbean/Black British background | 1 |
National identity [6]
Welsh | 53 |
---|---|
English | 6 |
British | 17 |
Other | 7 |
Did not respond | 3 |
Do you have any caring responsibilities? [7]
None | 58 |
---|---|
Primary carer of a child/children (under 18) | 19 |
Primary carer of a disabled child/children | 1 |
Secondary carer | 2 |
Prefer not to say | 1 |
Did not respond | 1 |
Disability - Do you consider yourself to have a disability?
Yes, day to day activities limited a lot | 2 |
---|---|
Yes, day to day activities limited a little | 2 |
No | 73 |
Prefer not to say | 1 |
Did not respond | 2 |
Disability - Do you have a disability, as defined by the Equality Act 2010?
Yes | 7 |
---|---|
No | 73 |
Grievance Procedures
No employees were involved in grievance procedures either as complainant, or as a person against whom a complaint was made, during 2023-24.
Disciplinary Procedures
No employees were subject to disciplinary procedures during 2023-24.
Leavers
As all employee equality data is anonymised, no specific data relating to the protected characteristics of employees who left the organisation is available.
Additional gender pay information as at 31 March 2024
Salary | Grade | Male | Female | Total |
---|---|---|---|---|
£23,258 - £26,901 | Team support | 0 | 2 | 2 |
£28,245 - £32,141 | EO | 8 | 19 | 27 |
£34,083 - £41,675 | HEO | 6 | 8 | 14 |
£43,785 - £51,839 | SEO | 2 | 6 | 8 |
£56,112 - £67,095 | Grade 7 | 0 | 1 | 1 |
£70,455 - £80,840 | Grade 6 | 1 | 2 | 3 |
£90,696 - £106,056 | Chief Executive | 1 | 0 | 1 |
Total | 18 | 38 | 56 |
Contract type | Male | Female | Total |
---|---|---|---|
Permanent | 17 | 38 | 55 |
Fixed term | 1 | 0 | 1 |
Temporary | 0 | 0 | 0 |
Total | 18 | 38 | 56 |
Working pattern | Male | Female | Total |
---|---|---|---|
Full time | 16 | 34 | 50 |
Part time | 2 | 4 | 6 |
Total | 18 | 38 | 56 |
Note: Analysis includes officers on maternity leave
[4] You’re disabled under the Equality Act 2010 if you have a physical or mental impairment that has a ‘substantial’ and ‘long-term’ negative effect on your ability to do normal daily activities.
[5] Some candidates identified themselves in more than one ethnic group.
[6] Some candidates identified themselves with more than one national identity.
[7] Some candidates selected more than option for their caring responsibilities.